Congress of the People in the Mother City

Archive for September, 2010|Monthly archive page

CASAC* IS TAKING THE BATON OF SOUND AND FURY FROM COPE?

In Discussion on September 30, 2010 at 10:20 am

* Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution

So, the businessman who was the first to bravely broach the subject of a political settlement for Jacob Zuma in the public arena in 2008 – when it was not fashionable to do so – is back on the front pages of our newspapers as a leader of civil society in defence of our constitution. You have to hand it to activist and business leader Sipho Pityana for reinventing himself far from the shadow of his brother Barney Pityana who shot to prominence at the back of the November convention two years ago.

The brothers would have been on the opposite ends of the pole when the national debate was reduced to how the ruling party intended to deal with the corruption charges facing the future head of state: a crucial constitutional matter.

Sipho Pityana fired the first salvo in September of 2008 literally calling on Zuma to be let off the hook in a muddled argument about the country’s stability. He wrote in the Mail and Guardian thus: “Would the prosecution of a sitting president not result in the kind of polarisation among criminal justice institutions that would make our country the playground of rogues and criminal elements?” This was clearly an argument crafted to undermine a straightforward process where all are equal before the law –otherwise known as the rule of law. Then came the lame caveat: “The dangers that come with seeking to change laws and institute special dispensations to deal with special circumstances are real.” It did not end there as he proceeded to the punchline….. “But to bury our heads in the sand and rigidly chase an oncoming train can be equally disastrous.”

So one is left only with the impression of constitutional obfuscation or is it a genuine desire to find a middle ground between clearly polarised positions on a hugely divisive issue?

His brother, respected Barney Pityana, was however a lot less nuanced at the November convention on November 1 2008, calling for leaders to take full responsibility. According to the Times Live, Barney Pityana said “there was a desperate need for a quality of leadership that has a moral consciousness embedded into them … and a leadership committed not just to themselves but first even above themselves to the well-being of the other.” He said that leadership has to be held accountable and must embrace and reflect the values of the people it seeks to represent- a clear reference to a position of no special favours to Zuma.

These two approaches to this issue makes it clear that the issues of the defence of the constitution will never be cut and dried. It is clear to me that this is why someone like Sipho Pityana who obviously is clear about the respect for the constitution even back then – was willing to explore options other than what he terms going against an oncoming train in the name of rigidity.

Today many can say to him trying to make sense of some of the tendency to bend the constitution by the ruling party is as good as going against a moving train. But he has now plucked up the courage to do so by leading what many see as the filling of the vacuum left by the demise of especially black opposition parties able to tackle the ANC.

Many commentators have argued that the only real opposition to the monolith that the ANC is will come from within. The dominance of ANC luminaries in Casac who themselves are not strangers to controversy is interesting as it may be dangerous to the course. The likes of Frene Ginwala who recently accused the ANC of deliberately undermining SCOPA and therefore parliament; the likes of Pikoli who are no strangers to speaking truth to power even if that got him fired; the likes of Kadar Asmal who has been shown the nearest grave by the MK Veterans and insulted by the firebrand Mbalula for daring to suggest that the ANC has lost its moral compass.

The role of these luminaries and more suggests that the only hope we have is the fixing of the ANC from within. I am not discounting the usual independent suspects such as Ramphele Mamphele, but one has to wonder why the luminaries thought it necessary to support and initiative that clearly points an accusatory finger at the ruling party. How do these loyal party members level such a serious accusation of endangering the constitution home – so much that you need such heavy weights in civil society to stand together and make their voices heard.

It is crucial however that if this initiative is to be taken seriously it must deal with the following ten matters currently threatening the constitution:

• The Media Tribunal: The council must oppose this terrible suggestion with all it can muster
• The Information Bill: This bill threatens to turn us into a secret society it must be rejected
• The truant judges: The judiciary will be the next target if it does not self correct.
• Disrespect of parliament: The recent political misconduct by the Minister of Defence is a symptom of things to come where the executive will run rough shod over parliament
• The undermining of chapter nine institutions: Kader Asmal must ask the question whatever happened to his report to streamline and strengthen these structures.
• The erosion of the NPA’s independence. The council must join in the reversal of Menzi Simelane’s appointment currently in front of the courts and being opposed by all sensible people.
• The systemic corruption: 2000 Civil servants have been recently fingered by SCOPA as having stolen 650 million Rands by doing business with themselves. Not a single one is in prison. There is something wrong there.
• Conflation of party and state. The council must support the mooted legislation that would deal with cadre deployment. Keeping the state and party separate is a good starting point to defend the constitution
• The council must support the prosecution of workers who strike in essential services but equally they must mount a campaign for the proper remuneration of civil servants to ensure that they should never resort to strikes that are fatal. The pursuit of second generation rights can defeat poverty.
• And finally should the issue of the prosecution of a sitting head of state arise. The council must not seek to skirt the issue like Sipho Pityana did in 2008 – they must reaffirm that no one is above the law and let the law take its course.

If Casac does not have the balls to confront the ruling elite in this way, it will go the way of the November convention and it will also earn itself a stanza from the powers that be as a ‘story told by an idiot full of sound and fury – signifying nothing’. Where the idiot is the luminaries whose gravitas has been wasted; where the sound and fury signifying nothing, is the stated intention to defend the constitution followed by no serious action while Rome continues to burn to the ground.

I HAVE HEARD AFRICA’S CALL

In Speeches on September 30, 2010 at 9:53 am

WHAT IS WRONG WITH AFRICA? I have heard Africa’s Call:
by Bishop Clyde N. Ramalaine

My tribute to former President Mbeki’s justified call for an African Renaissance:

The Chinese caligraphied minibus, we travelling in digs deep into the holes of what is considered a road in North Eastern Africa. These are not potholes these are agaping ditches in the roads attesting to lack of maintenance and infrastructure management. After having been thrown around from side to side in this meandering ride in which your intestines want to jump out of your entire soma, I finally get a chance to ask my host and friend, Why are the roads in Kampala capital of Uganda in this state? His answer is simple short yet definitive, “we have not yet received aid money”. Aid money I retort! I thought you build roads and maintain the same infrastructure with taxes Governments collect from its citizens informed by systems of control and management.

Needless to say I was in Africa, Uganda one of the first countries to have gone free, yet gripped in a cycle and evil of poverty, maladministration, a war ravaged country, economically challenged and still trying to shed the impact of dictatorial Amin I wish I could say this is unique to Uganda. Kampala where the stench of poverty envelopes the firmament and peoples faces are tired of fighting an invisible enemy attest so much the story for a great majority of what constitutes the African continent.

It is this dialectical tension based awareness that this continent who comes endowed with wealth in mineral resources untold, this soil that is rich in cultural expression, who has fed the entire world and make billionaires in far flung countries, who has exported its wealth and in return received a pittance rendering it strangled in abject poverty, hopelessness and defeat. This land bereft of human resources annihilated and denied of vision when “leaders” treats state coffers as their own petty cash boxes, must pull itself out of the abyss of evil.

It is the same observation that burnt so deep in an Nkrumah that he became compelled to argue, fight and reason for an African Consciousness. This consciousness advances a clear notion that Africa must free itself. Such vision impregnated another great mind of the Southland, who risked all even his presidency in pursuit of the re-awakening of the Nkrumah vision. Thabo Mbeki was pregnant with an African Renaissance, such renaissance draws from the confirmed claim that at some point in a history of history, Africa was a free land. Africa as a land that dictated the meridian of thought construct, Africa was a space where science was practiced until the pyramids testified. This land now barren of hope, gave linguistic definition to all languages in undergird, this land engineered the first trade and bartering systems. This Africa was expressive in its sophisticated cultural pursuit as identified by the many philosophers and concomitant history expressed in craft and effigies.

This is the Africa Nkrumah and Mbeki cries MAYIBUYE, out of this awareness of a history before a history. Mbeki took this conviction further in seeing the connectedness of the Africa that must re-awake, for him it was not about one country or one tribe it was and is and must always be about the ”all of Africa”. At the heart of this renaissance is the humanity aspect of that which constitutes Africanism. Such Africanism is not a mutually exclusive term but resonates on the plateau of a self awareness, and awareness of the bludgeoning of a people, the colossal rape committed, and awareness of the thuggery, an awareness of the gross injustice colonial forces inflicted as they sought to milk this land dry.

Not only is this awareness drawn from the impact of colonialism but a conjoined immured role of Africans themselves. This enslavement of a mind who only knows how to critique itself until self awareness evaporates into oblivion and self consciousness is seared. It is the realization of who Africa once was, that must impress on every African a sense of dignity, a blooming pride for ours is rich, ours is pure ours is a call to have Africa awake. Africa therefore must awake, such awakening is undergirded by a conscious conviction that no one, no force, no nation can free Africa but Africa must necessarily free itself. Martin Luther King jnr, in one of his best speeches on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial in Washington shortly before his death asserts.. We have come to our nation’s capital to cash a check.. For we refuse to accept that the well of justice is dried up and that the banks of freedom has gone bankrupt… In that same buoyant spirit Africa must cash its cheque, Africa must line up and demand its rightful space, Africa as represented in the sons and daughters of its soil must claim its stake for the claim of such is long overdue.

The problems with Africa are manifold so it’s claimed, dissertations case studies, research papers and books testify of this problem analysis, in which we somehow got stuck as we forever over analysing our history when praxis calls for implementation. Intellectuals have advanced hypothesis upon hypothesis. Ordinary Africans have oft out of frustration bellowed WHY US? Africa’s sons and daughters had left this vast land, in search of a future and a hope, they had obtained qualifications wherever they had gone they had left those in their company befuddled, mangled, stirred some even upset. They had shaken the foundations of countries where such countries questioned the very veracity of civilization of an Africa, whose sons proved the opposite.

Now I ask you what is wrong with Africa? If you expected me to list an endless litany of things that we have accused ourselves of in agreement with western world media, than u have failed to understand that Africa is conversing,

Africa is awaking, Africa is digging itself out of the Bermuda Triangle dug by colonialism, Africa is untying the shackles that Mary and Mary sings about, Africa is defying the Goree Bay enslavement, Africa is resisting the Robben Island banishment, Africa is rejecting the Savimbi wars of Angola and its accompanying blood diamond practice, Africa is condemning the genocide that redefined a Rwanda history, Africa is seeking peace in Sudan, Africa’s army is in Burundi guarding a fragile peace treaty, Africa is mediating in Somalia where one nation, with one tongue, an one religion is ravaged by a hate untold. Africa is talking about the rights of Eritreans.

This Africa is claiming its seashores back from pirate infested north east coast thugs, Africa is renegotiating mining deals that were born out of avarice. Today Africa is condemning dictators, that message must still reach Swaziland. Africa is saying to Big Brother Gaddafi this is not about individuals. Africa’s intellectuals are thinking again, Africa’s economists are hard at work seeking solutions for economic woes untold. Africa is saying to Uncle Bob in a Zimbabwe once the breadbasket of the south now the pariah state of the south, let God’s people go, vacate the seat, you have overstayed your welcome. KNaan’s melody challenge all to raise a flag, Keita’s song bellows it is your time, in the south Tsepo Tsola, the village pope, hums the battle cry of this awakening.

This Africa is saying to Nigeria, create a middle class that can sustain your nation. As the winds howl across Chad, and the dust gathers over Gambia, the drumbeat is heard from deep in the Congo, the cry of the owl retorts in Ghana its time. Reminding Algeria, Morocco regardless of skin tone you are African. Africa’s cry to Azania – Mzansi lead the way.

Africa is rising from the slum hinterland of Destitute-Ville, Africa’s sun is rising, Africa’s horn is being raised, and Africa is finding its history before history.

The irrevocable challenge for you and I is to respond to Africa’s call . What shall our response be? Are you a part, are you on the fence, are you in awaking too or do you live in assessment and analysis world until you do not sense such awakening?

What is wrong with Africa, I simply shall contend, AN ABSENCE OF MORE AFRICANS RAISING THEIRS HANDS.

Bishop Clyde N. S. Ramalaine

FROM PRESIDENT MBEKI

Your Grace Bishop Ramalaine,

Many, many thanks for your tribute and your wise words which convey the very welcome and truly inspiring message that Africa is blessed to have sons and daughters, like Your Grace, who will surely ensure that she rises from the ashes.

Many a time one feels a great sense of loneliness that as we act and speak everyday, driven by the vision and dream of an Africa reborn, we are like lost souls wandering across the great expanses of the Sahara Desert, with only the mighty and silent sand dunes on the African landscape as our audience.

It is only when we hear African patriots, such as Your Grace, speaking out as you have, that we gain assurance and strength from the knowledge that there is somebody out there, especially on our Continent, who is listening attentively and is ready to act to restore to us our dignity.

Thus does it become possible to stop shouting out the question and the plea – is there anybody there!

The sand dunes do not answer except by echoing the question back, helpful because they amplify the voice in the hope that another African, beyond the reach of the voice of the lonely traveller, will hear the echo and use the stereophonic voice of the sand dunes to answer the lonely traveller that – yes, there is somebody there!

Many a day the traveller stands surrounded by African sands that stretch as far as the eye can see, waiting, waiting for even a faint voice that says yes – there is somebody there!

Much too often the sound of a voice wafts over saying – yes, there is somebody there! But as often, this proves to be a mirage, which confirms the cruel ability of the desert to delude the thirsty traveller that what he or she sees as a water-filled oasis is but mere illusion!

But then suddenly a human and real person, an African, emerges from over the horizon to say that – yes, there are other Africans over there, even on what seem to be the desolate expanses of the African deserts. These are other Africans who hold firmly to the dream that Africa will be reborn, and that the deserts are only barren in what they seem to be.

These come to tell the truth that within their unseen depths, the African sands harbour life and life-giving water that must comfort the traveller that the African deserts do not portend death, but constitute a challenge to African ingenuity and the African mind to discover in the African deserts what they hold and hide in store, preserved for the generations as a resource without limit, to sustain a new and African life of our fulfilment at last and the recovery of our dignity, at last.

Your Grace might have heard me a number of times reciting lines from a poem by the Irish poet, W.B. Yeats, The Second Coming. The poem includes an ominous image expressed in the words:


The Second Coming! Hardly are those words out / When a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi / Troubles my sight: somewhere in the sands of the desert / A shape with lion body and the head of a man, / A gaze blank and pitiless as the sun, / Is moving its slow thighs, while all about it / Reel shadows of the indignant desert birds. / The darkness drops again; but now I know / That twenty centuries of stony sleepwere vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle, / And what rough beast, its hour come round at last, / Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?

I remembered these words when I read what you had written, when, borne on the wings of your thoughts, I saw you emerge from beyond the horizon of the African desert, as though to respond to the echo of my cry carried by the desert winds – is there anybody there!

When I enveloped myself in your thoughts, I could see that no!, what I could see was not a menacing figure with “a shape with lion body and the head of a man”, and not “a rough beast, its hour come round at last”, but a beautiful African who was singing a beautiful melody in a beautiful voice, summoning us to dance a dance that foresees and celebrates Africa’s rebirth.

I overcame my fear and sense of foreboding when I came to realise that what I was seeing was not a “rough beast” that was “slouching towards Bethlehem to be born”, but a harbinger of the African future towards which Africans, through the ages, have aspired and for whose realisation they have sacrificed everything, including their lives.

I understood therefore why you questioned why the roads in Kampala were marred by potholes which African hands could easily repair, without waiting for another to donate to us ordinary asphalt and picks and shovels, to make our roads smooth again, able to carry the African traveller without submission to a ‘meandering ride on which, needlessly, your intestines want to jump out of your entire soma’.

Thus has Your Grace placed the challenge at our African feet, to take the task into our own hands to smoothe Africa’s road to her own rebirth.

Your Grace has made the profound statement that indlela yaziwa ngabayihambayo – only we, the Africans, know that the road we walk as Africans is marked by potholes.

Surely, because we, rather than another, know the state of the road we have to travel, have an obligation to repair it, because we, and nobody else, carry the burden and the pain of navigating the potholes, in the event that we allow them to remain, a hazard along our way to the glorious African future which our ancestors and predecessors, to this day, and wherever they are, urge us to transform into our present and theirs.

Your Grace, many thanks for the heartfelt plea you have made when you asked the troubling question – What is wrong with Africa?

Together with you we must make the commitment to answer this important question, determined to correct everything that has gone wrong, in practical ways!

Together, as Africans, and as you say, correctly, those of us who have the will, however few we may be, must raise our hands to affirm that we refuse to sit on the fence, having resolved that we too, whatever the cost, are and will continue to be part of the African awakening.

Many thanks and warm regards.

Thabo Mbeki.

September 18, 2010.

COPE’s missing edge

In Editorials on September 27, 2010 at 3:46 pm

A sharp knife is a powerful weapon for attack as well as a critical tool for survival. Yet, a blunt knife is a terrible disgrace!

COPE had the opportunity to be the sharp edge of South African politics. With corruption and power mongering slowly but surely reversing the gains of democracy and our struggle for a better life for all, the knife designed for surgical precision to deal with the many cancers in our society is instead being used to deal with fellow comrades in a race for positions of power and reward.

The call from South Africa for a credible opposition to deal a vital blow to the growing tyranny goes completely unanswered. COPE squandered its opportunity to be the answer for our country. Instead, today it is as much a disgrace as a blunt knife in the day of trouble and need.

What will give us our edge back?

We must all personally gather our resolve, dig deep, clarify our vision and choose to:

  • Sacrifice for the greater good.
  • Forfeit personal goals and ambitions for the sake of the cause.
  • Recognise the true need of our party and elect strong, capable leaders who will use the knife to defend the weak and poor and battle for the soul of our country.

Let us acknowledge our failure to heed the right call. Let us sharpen our swords and go to battle for a higher cause. If some decide to continue to fight personal and selfish battles there is little we can do but to leave them behind in their pitiful state.

Today COPE must answer the call of our country – the call of our people.

AMANDLA!

Johan Boot